Honoring the past, covering the present & securing the future

Auto

Home

Business

Life

Group Health

Toy Vehicles

Affordable Insurance

from Your Independent Insurance Agents

Contact Lancaster Insurance Agency, where integrity and innovation result in the most affordable insurance tailored to your precise needs. We’re a private agency for many different insurance providers and specialize in finding policies that are right for you. Whether you require auto, home, or business insurance, we will discuss your policy options with you to make sure you have everything that you need.
Stop by our office today or give us a call to discuss your insurance needs.

Instant Insurance Quote

In a hurry? Get a quote on your insurance policy instantly.

Get Started
Get an instant quote today!

We Are
Here For
You

Get Started With a Quote

Featured Carriers

Aegis Logo
American Modern Logo
Arlington Roe Logo
Bristol West Logo
BTIS Logo
Erie Logo
Hanover Logo
Hauler’s Logo
Liberty Mutual Logo
Madison Mutual Logo
National General Logo
Progressive Logo
SafeCo Logo
Universal Logo

From the initial call to the Lancaster team to the decreased rates for our auto insurance this team is the BEST! If you’re looking for an insurance company that is personable, professional or just overall a better financial option this...

-Christopher Schmitt

I recently had the pleasure of working with Lancaster, and I couldn't be more impressed with the level of service I received. From the very first call, Molly and her team were incredibly professional, helpful, and attentive to my needs....

-Caleb Voegel

Highly recommend! Molly's professionalism and knowledge truly set her apart. It's clear she genuinely cares about her clients and goes the extra mile to ensure all their needs are met. If you're looking for top-notch service and someone you can...

-Annie Pettinga

A great choice! I have known Mollie O'Daniel for thirty years. She's incredibly diligent, smart, and kind. She will help you match with the right company and coverage. Amazing integrity and ethical standards.

-Gayle Gerling Pettinga

View More

What Clients Say

Our Latest Articles

December 23, 2025

Health Care – Individual Plans: What You Need to Know 

Navigating health insurance can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re looking for coverage outside of an employer-sponsored plan. At , we understand the importance […]

November 30, 2025

Personal Umbrella Coverage: What You Need to Know 

A single lawsuit may put assets and future earnings at risk. Personal umbrella insurance can provide extra liability coverage when standard policies may fall short, […]

October 29, 2025

Fender Bender or Full Crash? How to Know What Your Auto Insurance Really Covers 

Understanding what your auto insurance covers is essential for every driver, whether you’ve experienced a minor fender bender or a […]